EVALUATION AND USE OF THE CONCLUSION OF FORENSIC HANDBOOK EXAMINATION OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE GRAPHICAL MANUSCRIPTS IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
Journal: FORENSIC EXAMINATION
№ 1
, 2024
Authors:
1.
Moskovskiy universitet MVD Rossii im. V. Ya. Kikotya
graduate student
graduate student
Type:
Article
Pages:
from 32
to 40
Status:
Published
Received:
21.01.2024
Accepted:
24.01.2024
Published:
27.03.2024
Subject area:
UDC 343.982.4
Language:
Russian
Keywords:
ASSESSMENT AND USE OF THE CONCLUSION OF A FORENSIC HANDWRITING EXAMINATION OF MANUSCRIPTS OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE GRAPHIC COMPOSITION, CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS, COMPREHENSIVE LINGUISTIC AND FORENSIC HANDWRITING RESEARCH, ADMISSIBILITY, RELEVANCE, RELIABILITY, SUFFICIENCY OF THE CONCLUSION TO RESOLVE THE CASE
Abstract:
The article discusses the issues of assessing and using the conclusion of a forensic handwriting examination of manuscripts of foreign language graphic composition in criminal proceedings. The opinion is expressed that the basic legal requirements for the assessment of evidence apply in full to the assessment of the conclusion of a forensic handwriting examination of foreign language manuscripts. At the same time, it is necessary to take into account the specifics of this process, which consists in a consistent assessment of the results of a comprehensive linguistic and forensic handwriting study according to the criteria of admissibility, relevance, reliability and sufficiency for resolving the case. It is concluded that in criminal proceedings, facts established by forensic handwriting examination of foreign language manuscripts are used during special events before the initiation of a criminal case, preliminary investigation and trial. They have evidentiary and guiding value in establishing the event and corpus delicti, the involvement of certain persons in it, and other circumstances of the case. On their basis, operational search activities and investigative actions are also carried out, and judicial decisions are made.
The article discusses the issues of assessing and using the conclusion of a forensic handwriting examination of manuscripts of foreign language graphic composition in criminal proceedings. The opinion is expressed that the basic legal requirements for the assessment of evidence apply in full to the assessment of the conclusion of a forensic handwriting examination of foreign language manuscripts. At the same time, it is necessary to take into account the specifics of this process, which consists in a consistent assessment of the results of a comprehensive linguistic and forensic handwriting study according to the criteria of admissibility, relevance, reliability and sufficiency for resolving the case. It is concluded that in criminal proceedings, facts established by forensic handwriting examination of foreign language manuscripts are used during special events before the initiation of a criminal case, preliminary investigation and trial. They have evidentiary and guiding value in establishing the event and corpus delicti, the involvement of certain persons in it, and other circumstances of the case. On their basis, operational search activities and investigative actions are also carried out, and judicial decisions are made.
Keywords:
ASSESSMENT AND USE OF THE CONCLUSION OF A FORENSIC HANDWRITING EXAMINATION OF MANUSCRIPTS OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE GRAPHIC COMPOSITION, CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS, COMPREHENSIVE LINGUISTIC AND FORENSIC HANDWRITING RESEARCH, ADMISSIBILITY, RELEVANCE, RELIABILITY, SUFFICIENCY OF THE CONCLUSION TO RESOLVE THE CASE
ASSESSMENT AND USE OF THE CONCLUSION OF A FORENSIC HANDWRITING EXAMINATION OF MANUSCRIPTS OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE GRAPHIC COMPOSITION, CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS, COMPREHENSIVE LINGUISTIC AND FORENSIC HANDWRITING RESEARCH, ADMISSIBILITY, RELEVANCE, RELIABILITY, SUFFICIENCY OF THE CONCLUSION TO RESOLVE THE CASE
1. Orlov Yu. K. Expert opinion and its assessment (in criminal cases). Textbook. Moscow: Lawyer; 1995: 64. (In Russ.).
2. Rossinskaya E. R. Forensic examination in civil, arbitration, administrative and criminal proceedings. Moscow: Norma; 2011: 736. (In Russ.).
3. Averyanova T. V. Forensic examination: general theory course. Moscow: Norma; 2006: 480. (In Russ.).
4. Bobovkin M. V., Ruchkin V. A. On the specifics of assessing the conclusion of a handwriting expert. Forensic expert, 3-6, 2019. (In Russ.).
